Red Sox's Willson Contreras Fumes After Brother Snubbed for NLCS MVP
Red Sox first baseman Willson Contreras made his feelings about the National League Championship Series MVP vote crystal clear Thursday night — then quickly tried to take it back.
A Family Feud Ignites After the Pennant
Shortly after the Milwaukee Brewers completed a four-game sweep of the Los Angeles Dodgers on Thursday to win their first pennant since 1982, Contreras took to Instagram to argue that his brother William — Milwaukee's star catcher — deserved the NLCS MVP award over teammate Jake Bauers.
In a series of three now-deleted Instagram stories, Contreras posted a photo of his brother wearing a crown with the caption "THE REAL MVP," followed by a screenshot of William's postseason numbers captioned "Numbers don't lie." A third story carried the pointed line, "Tell me where you are from, and I'll give you the MVP," which many interpreted as an accusation of bias in the voting.
Per reports from EssentiallySports and albat.com, Contreras deleted two of the three stories, but screenshots had already been captured by the Talkin' Baseball account on X before they disappeared.
The Numbers: Did He Have a Point?
Statistically, Contreras' frustration is easy to understand. William Contreras slashed .367/.457/.700 with three home runs and five RBIs across 35 plate appearances this postseason, according to EssentiallySports — numbers that dwarfed Bauers' .269/.441/.423 line with one homer and six RBIs.
But MVP voters rewarded Bauers' timeliness. The journeyman first baseman delivered huge moments in Games 2, 3 and 4, including a rally-starting fourth-inning double in the clincher, when Milwaukee stormed back from a 4-0 deficit to win 6-4 at Dodger Stadium on Oct. 15. Bauers drove in six runs across the four games, finishing with four hits and three walks.
Even the losing side conceded Milwaukee's dominance. "We got outplayed in all facets," Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said after the sweep, in comments quoted in a Substack recap of the series.
What's Next
The fallout lands awkwardly for the Contreras brothers: William's Brewers are headed to their first World Series in 44 years, where they will face the winner of the Guardians-Rays ALCS while chasing the first championship in franchise history. And with Willson's deleted posts already circulating league-wide, the veteran slugger can expect questions the next time he faces reporters — the story adds a personal edge to what was already a landmark October for Milwaukee.

